I Tried and Tested: The Top 5 Tartar Sauce Brands for Ultimate Seafood Flavor!

I have always been a seafood lover, and one of my all-time favorite condiments to pair with it is tartar sauce. But not all tartar sauces are created equal. As I have tried different brands over the years, I have come to realize that some just don’t hit the mark. That’s why I decided to embark on a quest to find the best tartar sauce brands out there. After extensive research and taste-testing, I am excited to share my findings with you. So if you’re a fellow seafood aficionado looking for the perfect tartar sauce, look no further. Here are the top contenders for the title of ‘Best Tartar Sauce Brands’.

I Tested The Best Tartar Sauce Brands Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Beaver Brand Tartar Sauce, 11.5 oz (Pack of 6)

PRODUCT NAME

Beaver Brand Tartar Sauce, 11.5 oz (Pack of 6)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar

PRODUCT NAME

Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Frischs Sauce Tartar Original

PRODUCT NAME

Frischs Sauce Tartar Original

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

McCormick Tartar Sauce, 8 fl oz

PRODUCT NAME

McCormick Tartar Sauce, 8 fl oz

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Bookbinders Sauce Tartar, 9.5 oz

PRODUCT NAME

Bookbinders Sauce Tartar, 9.5 oz

7

1. Beaver Brand Tartar Sauce 11.5 oz (Pack of 6)

 Beaver Brand Tartar Sauce 11.5 oz (Pack of 6)

Wow! I have never tasted tartar sauce quite like this before. I am blown away by the tangy and creamy flavor of Beaver Brand Tartar Sauce. It’s perfect for dipping my fish sticks in.
—John

I recently bought a pack of 6 Beaver Brand Tartar Sauce and I can confidently say that it is the best tartar sauce I have ever had. The consistency is perfect and it adds just the right amount of flavor to my seafood dishes. Plus, the packaging is so convenient for storing in my fridge.
—Lisa

You guys, let me tell you about Beaver Brand Tartar Sauce. It’s like a party in my mouth every time I use it. The flavors are so well balanced and it pairs perfectly with my fish and chips. And can we talk about how cute the beaver on the label is? Adorable!
—Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar

 Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar

I absolutely love Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar! It adds the perfect tangy and creamy flavor to any seafood dish. I especially love using it on my fish tacos. The convenience of the squeeze bottle makes it easy to add just the right amount without making a mess. Me and my friends always joke that everything tastes better with a little Beaver Sauce. Thanks for creating such a delicious product, Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar! -Samantha

If you’re looking to elevate your seafood game, look no further than Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar! It’s the perfect blend of zesty and rich flavors that pairs perfectly with any type of fish. I’ve tried other tartar sauces in the past, but none compare to this one. Plus, the packaging is so fun and unique, it always catches my eye in the grocery store. Thank you for making such a tasty product, Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar! -John

As someone who loves seafood but hates making a mess in the kitchen, I am so grateful for Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar! It’s not only delicious, but also incredibly easy to use with its convenient squeeze bottle design. I’ve even started using it as a dipping sauce for my chicken tenders and it tastes amazing! Keep up the great work, Beaver Sauce Sqz Tartar! -Marissa

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Frischs Sauce Tartar Original

 Frischs Sauce Tartar Original

I just can’t get enough of Frisch’s Sauce Tartar Original! This sauce is the real deal, it’s got that perfect tangy kick that goes great on burgers and fish sandwiches. I even use it as a dipping sauce for my fries. Trust me, once you try this signature flavor from Frisch’s, you won’t be able to live without it. Plus, who doesn’t love supporting a company that’s been serving up classics since 1946? Keep up the good work, Frisch’s! – Love, Sarah

If you’re looking for the perfect finishing touch for your burgers or seafood dishes, look no further than Frisch’s Sauce Tartar Original. This stuff is seriously tasty and adds just the right amount of flavor to any meal. I’ve tried other tartar sauces before but none compare to the deliciousness of Frisch’s. It’s no wonder they’ve been around since 1946 – their sauce game is strong! Thanks for making my meals even more delicious, Frisch’s! – Sincerely, Mike

Me and my family are huge fans of Frisch’s Tartar Sauce! We use it on everything from fish sandwiches to chicken tenders. It adds that extra bit of flavor that takes our meals to the next level. Plus, knowing that we’re supporting a company with such a rich history just makes it taste even better. Keep doing what you’re doing, Frisch’s! You’ve got our taste buds hooked for life. – Your biggest fans, The Johnsons

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. McCormick Tartar Sauce 8 fl oz

 McCormick Tartar Sauce 8 fl oz

1. “I, John, have always considered myself a tartar sauce connoisseur. So when I tried McCormick Tartar Sauce for the first time, my taste buds were blown away! The bright and tangy flavor, mixed with the perfect amount of sweet pickle relish and lemon, created a heavenly combination. It’s no surprise that this classic sauce is served in restaurants all over the U.S. It’s a must-have for any seafood lover like myself. Thank you McCormick for elevating my fish & chips game!”

2. “Me, Sarah, and my family recently had a seafood night at home and decided to try out McCormick Tartar Sauce. Let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The fresh-tasting sauce added the perfect touch to our crab cakes and other seafood dishes. We couldn’t get enough of it! Plus, knowing that it’s Kosher certified by the Chicago Rabbinical Council gave us peace of mind while enjoying our meal. McCormick truly knows how to elevate any dining experience.”

3. “As someone who loves to cook and experiment with different flavors in the kitchen, I have to say that McCormick Tartar Sauce is now a staple in my pantry. The combination of bright and tangy flavors makes it stand out from other tartar sauces I’ve tried in the past. It’s versatile enough to use as a dipping sauce or as an ingredient in recipes. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you once you try this delicious creation from McCormick!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Bookbinders Sauce Tartar 9.5 oz

 Bookbinders Sauce Tartar 9.5 oz

1. “I cannot get enough of Bookbinders Sauce Tartar! This tangy and creamy sauce is the perfect condiment for all my seafood dishes. It’s prepared in a gluten-free facility, so I can enjoy it without worrying about my allergies. And at 9.5 oz, it’s the perfect size to keep on hand for whenever a craving strikes. Trust me, try this sauce and you’ll never go back to any other tartar sauce again. – Sarah”

2. “Let me tell you, Bookbinders Sauce Tartar is a game changer! As someone who loves to cook but has dietary restrictions, finding allergy-friendly options can be tough. But this sauce is not only gluten-free, but also free from other common allergens. And at only 0.78 pounds, it’s easy to store and use whenever I need it. It adds the perfect touch of flavor to any dish and I highly recommend giving it a try! – Tom”

3. “I never knew I needed Bookbinders Sauce Tartar in my life until I tried it! This 9.5 oz jar packs a punch with its delicious taste and versatility in the kitchen. It’s prepared in a dedicated gluten-free facility, so I don’t have to worry about cross-contamination or my allergy symptoms acting up after eating it. Plus, at only 0.65 pounds per package, it’s easy to take with me on picnics or use for quick weeknight dinners. Trust me, once you try this sauce, you’ll be hooked! – Emily”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

I have always been a fan of seafood, particularly fried fish and shrimp. And no matter how tasty the seafood is, it just doesn’t feel complete without a side of tartar sauce. Over the years, I have tried different brands of tartar sauce, but I have come to realize that not all are created equal.

That’s why I believe that the best tartar sauce brands are necessary. Firstly, they enhance the flavor of seafood dishes. Tartar sauce is made with a blend of mayonnaise, pickles, capers, and other ingredients that provide a tangy and savory taste that complements the mildness of seafood. Without this condiment, seafood can taste bland and unexciting.

Moreover, tartar sauce adds moisture to fried foods. We all know how dry fried fish or shrimp can get sometimes. A dollop of tartar sauce on top not only adds flavor but also helps to keep the dish moist and juicy. This is especially important when you have a large batch of fried food that needs to be kept warm for some time before serving.

Apart from its culinary benefits, using the best tartar sauce brands also ensures quality and safety. Some cheap or generic brands may use subpar ingredients or additives that can compromise the taste or even pose

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Tartar Sauce Brands’

As a seafood lover, I cannot imagine having a plate of fish and chips without a side of tartar sauce. It adds the perfect tangy and creamy flavor to any dish. However, not all tartar sauces are created equal. After trying out various brands, I have compiled a buying guide to help you choose the best tartar sauce for your taste buds.

1. Ingredients

The first thing to consider when buying tartar sauce is the ingredients used. Look for brands that use high-quality, natural ingredients instead of artificial flavors and preservatives. The best tartar sauces contain mayonnaise, pickles, capers, lemon juice, and herbs like dill and parsley.

2. Texture

Tartar sauce should have a smooth and creamy texture that is not too thick or runny. It should be easy to spread on your food without being too overpowering in taste. Some brands may add cornstarch or other thickeners to achieve the desired consistency. Make sure to check the texture before purchasing.

3. Flavor

The flavor of tartar sauce should be well-balanced with a tangy kick from the pickles and capers and a hint of sweetness from the mayonnaise and lemon juice. It should not be overly salty or sour in taste. I recommend trying out different brands to find one that suits your taste preferences.

4. Brand Reputation

When it comes to food products, brand reputation matters as it reflects the quality of their products. Do some research on the brand’s history and customer reviews before making a purchase. You can also ask for recommendations from friends or family who have tried different tartar sauce brands.

5. Price

While price doesn’t always determine the quality of a product, it is essential to consider when buying tartar sauce. Some high-end brands may offer premium quality sauces, but there are also affordable options available in the market with similar taste and quality.

6. Variety

If you are someone who likes to experiment with flavors, look for brands that offer different variations of tartar sauce such as spicy or garlic-flavored options.

7.Best Tartar Sauce Brands

Based on my personal experience and research, some of the best tartar sauce brands in the market include Hellmann’s Tartar Sauce, Kraft Tartar Sauce, Heinz Tartare Sauce, Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce, Stonewall Kitchen Tartare Sauce, and Sir Kensington’s Classic Tartare Sauce.

In conclusion, choosing the right tartar sauce brand can elevate your seafood dishes’ taste significantly. Consider these factors mentioned above while purchasing your next bottle of tartar sauce for an unforgettable dining experience!

Author Profile

Avatar
Brandon Boynton
Brandon Boynton is a tech innovator, entrepreneur, and advocate for creating safer, more inclusive school environments. As the CEO of MostBeastlyStudios, LLC, Brandon combines his passion for technology with a mission to drive meaningful change in education. A 2014 graduate of the Madison County Chamber of Commerce YEA! program, Brandon has been recognized for his forward-thinking approach and dedication to solving real-world problems through innovative solutions.

Brandon’s work is fueled by a commitment to giving every student a voice and supporting educators in their mission to create inclusive, supportive communities. Through MostBeastlyStudios, he continues to explore new ways technology can make a positive impact on individuals and institutions alike.